Buttermilk Pie Recipe: Southern Living Classic Custard

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe

Oh, I just adore a dessert that feels like a warm hug, don’t you? That silky-smooth custard, with its delicate tang and sweet aroma, truly defines the buttermilk pie recipe Southern Living classic custard style. It’s an old-fashioned favorite, surprisingly simple to whip up even on a busy Tuesday evening for a hearty family dinner. This easy, family-friendly recipe brings authentic Southern charm to your table. We’ve refined this specific buttermilk pie recipe to ensure a foolproof taste that captures the heart of Southern baking, offering both comfort and a delicious finish to any meal.

What You’ll Need (Ingredients and Why They Matter)

Our beloved buttermilk pie recipe Southern Living classic custard style relies on simple pantry staples, making it a cost-effective and easy dinner idea dessert. This delightful buttermilk pie recipe shows how simple ingredients can create something truly special. I always keep these on hand for spur-of-the-moment baking.

1 (9-inch/23 cm) unbaked pie crust: For a tender base. (Use store-bought for ultimate ease or your favorite homemade for premium quality.)
1 ½ cups (300g) granulated sugar: Balances the tangy buttermilk for perfect sweetness.
¼ cup (30g) all-purpose flour: Thickens the filling for that classic custard style. (Swap with a gluten-free blend for a GF option.)

½ cup (113g) unsalted butter, melted: Adds richness and flavor. (Using high-quality unsalted butter makes a noticeable difference.)
1 ½ cups (360ml) full-fat buttermilk: The star! Provides that signature tangy flavor and tender crumb. (No buttermilk? Add 1 ½ Tbsp lemon juice or white vinegar to regular milk for a quick substitute.)
3 large eggs: Essential for the classic custard style, giving richness and setting the pie. (Farm-fresh eggs lend a beautiful, deeper yellow hue.)

1 tsp (5ml) vanilla extract: A touch of warmth and aromatic sweetness.
Pinch of salt (¼ tsp / 1.5g): Enhances all the flavors.

Flavor Boosters:

A light sprinkle of nutmeg or cinnamon on top adds warmth and depth.

A hint of lemon or orange zest brightens the flavor profile for a refreshing twist.

Easy Step-by-Step Cooking Guide

Prepare Your Crust (10-15 min prep, 15 min chill): Fit your preferred 9-inch (23 cm) pie crust into a pie plate. If blind baking for a crispier bottom, follow your crust’s directions until lightly golden and firm. I always use my ceramic pie plate for an even bake, finding it helps prevent a soggy bottom.
Whisk Up the Buttermilk Filling (5-7 min): In a large bowl, whisk together the granulated sugar, all-purpose flour, and salt. Gradually add the buttermilk, melted butter, eggs, and vanilla extract. Whisk until the mixture is smooth and a creamy, pale yellow, without lumps. This creates the rich base for your perfect buttermilk pie recipe Southern Living classic custard style.

Pour and Bake (45-60 min): Carefully pour the buttermilk mixture into your prepared pie crust. Bake at 350°F (175°C) for 45-60 minutes. The edges will be golden, and the center 2-3 inches should still have a slight jiggle when gently nudged. If your pie is browning too fast, loosely tent the edges with foil to prevent over-darkening. This gentle wobble means it’s just right for that classic custard setting.
Cool and Chill (2-4 hours): Let the pie cool completely on a wire rack for at least an hour. Then, transfer it to the refrigerator and chill for a minimum of 2 hours. This chilling step is essential for the classic custard style to fully set, allowing for clean, beautiful slices. Without this, your buttermilk pie recipe won’t hold its shape as intended.

For quick meals on busy nights, remember a store-bought pie crust is a convenient time-saver. You can also melt butter in the microwave for speedier prep and fewer dishes. If making a gluten-free pie, ensure all ingredients, including your pie crust, are certified gluten-free for a truly compliant and delicious dessert.

Serving Ideas, Pairings, and Make-Ahead Uses

This classic buttermilk pie recipe, Southern Living classic custard style, shines for any occasion.

Perfect moments to serve: weeknight dinners, holidays, lunchboxes.

A comforting dessert for family dinners or weeknights.

Ideal for holiday gatherings or Sunday brunch.

Pair with sides, sauces, or drinks.

Serve with fresh whipped cream or vanilla ice cream.
Enjoy with coffee or sweet iced tea.

Prep in advance: storage containers, fridge/freezer times, reheating tips.

Baked pie made 1-2 days ahead for meal prep recipes. Refrigerate 3-4 days. Freeze slices up to 1 month.

Wellness and Lifestyle Benefits with Buttermilk Pie

Homemade buttermilk pie recipe offers benefits for a balanced lifestyle.

Tie recipe to popular lifestyle goals: balanced eating, high-protein meals, energy support.

Satisfies sweet cravings without excess.
Homemade goodness means ingredient control.

Emphasize qualities like quick prep, family-friendly, nutrient-rich.

Nutrient-rich from eggs and dairy.

An easy dinner idea and classic comfort food.

Everyday Value and Flexibility

This delightful buttermilk pie recipe, Southern Living classic custard style, offers great kitchen value.

Show how Buttermilk Pie saves money, reduces waste, or fits into weekly meal plans.

Cost-effective: uses affordable pantry staples.
Reduces waste: great for leftover buttermilk.

Versatile: Adapts to various occasions and dietary needs with simple tweaks.

This pie adapts easily to different tastes, proving its home kitchen flexibility.

Chef’s Notes and Customization Options

Elevate your buttermilk pie recipe, Southern Living Classic Custard Style, with simple tricks.

Advanced flavor or texture tweaks.

For richer filling, replace some buttermilk with heavy cream.
I blind bake my pie crust until light golden to prevent a soggy bottom.

Spice and seasoning variations for different tastes.

Add cardamom or ginger for a unique twist.

Infuse buttermilk with lemon peel for brighter taste.

Substitutions for kids, allergies, or diet restrictions.

Kid-friendly: Sprinkle mini chocolate chips on crust.
Vegan option: Use vegan crust, flax eggs, plant-based substitutes.

Common Questions Answered

Q: Is buttermilk pie suitable for low-carb diets?

Traditional buttermilk pie isn’t low-carb. Explore recipes using low-carb sweeteners and almond/coconut flour for keto versions, though the classic custard style will differ.

Q: Can I order buttermilk pie ingredients online?

Absolutely! Most supermarkets offer online ordering for all standard ingredients. Find specialty crusts or gluten-free alternatives for your buttermilk pie recipe southern living classic custard style easily.

Q: What’s the best way to store leftovers of buttermilk pie?

Store leftover buttermilk pie tightly covered in the refrigerator for 3-4 days, best chilled. Freeze individual slices up to one month, thawing in the fridge.

Q: My buttermilk pie cracked on top, what went wrong?

Cracks usually result from overbaking or rapid cooling. If the custard is already set, it can crack. Reduce bake time slightly or cool more gradually.

Q: Can I use regular milk if I don’t have buttermilk?

Make a buttermilk substitute with 1 tbsp lemon juice/vinegar per cup of milk. True buttermilk provides the most authentic tangy flavor for this classic buttermilk pie recipe Southern Living Classic Custard Style.

Q: How do I know when my buttermilk pie is done baking?

Edges should be set, but the center should still jiggle slightly. A knife near the edge comes out clean. Overbaking creates a firmer texture and cracks.

Conclusion

This easy buttermilk pie recipe, Southern Living classic custard style, offers authentic Southern comfort, big flavor, and nostalgia.

I hope you try this family-friendly dessert soon! Save this buttermilk pie recipe to Pinterest for future sweet cravings.